How to audit a crypto signal history
A practical ledger for original messages, amendments, cancellations and unresolved positions.
Compare fixed-notional fees, slippage and subscription cost without confusing leverage with an edge.
Public-document research and educational exercises. No paid-room tracking, exchange connection or audited customer return is claimed.
Compare costs in account currency and against a declared notional amount. A percentage of posted margin is not the same thing as a percentage of trade notional or account equity. Leverage changes exposure and liquidation risk; it does not remove transaction costs or prove that a signal has an advantage.
For a fictional $2,000 fixed-notional round trip, one basis point is $0.20. Eight basis points of total fees cost $1.60. If the assumed spread and slippage add twelve basis points, execution friction totals $4.00 before subscription, funding, borrowing and taxes.
An illustrative $30 monthly subscription divided across ten completed ideas allocates $3 to each idea. Across only two completed ideas it allocates $15. Neither is an observed provider price. A buyer should use the actual invoice, taxes and refund terms and count the ideas they were practically able to follow, not every message published.
Do not scale the number of trades simply to make a subscription look inexpensive. More turnover can increase fees and correlated risk. A useful comparison keeps the intended activity and notional fixed, then asks how much gross benefit is needed to cover total cost.
A funding payment can be a debit or a credit depending on the contract, direction, observed rate and payment boundary. Do not assume every venue has the same interval or that the current rate continues for an entire hold. Borrowing costs on a margin position are a different item from perpetual funding.
Use the exact contract specification and account statement. If the next funding event is unknown, publish scenarios rather than a fabricated forecast. Avoid double-counting a funding item already included in the exchange's reported realised outcome.
A publisher may report the movement from an ideal entry to the highest later price. Your order may fill later, partially or not at all. Preserve both values with their definitions. Subtracting a generic fee from a best-price screenshot does not reconstruct a subscriber trade.
In the example above, a 0.5% gross move on $2,000 is $10. After $4 execution friction and $3 allocated subscription cost, $3 remains before other charges. A small change in assumptions can erase it. The example demonstrates arithmetic, not a profitable trading setup.
Before paying, request the population definition, cancellation policy, renewal terms and a sample export. Compare a no-subscription baseline with the same exposure and execution assumptions. A fee can be modest while the evidence is still insufficient; an expensive service is not automatically fraudulent.
The strongest practical output is a written purchase condition: what must be inspectable, what remains unknown and which risk would stop the purchase. Do not turn an educational break-even calculation into expected income or a recommendation to increase leverage.
A practical ledger for original messages, amendments, cancellations and unresolved positions.
Review API scope, open orders, copied positions and revocation before connecting automation.
Six new cost rows retain gross direction and after-cost illustration as different fields. EDU-07 is a gross winner but a hypothetical net loser; EDU-08 subtracts negative financing as a credit. No actual fee tier, invoice, quantity or account capital path is supplied. The rows therefore demonstrate sign and unit handling without aggregating into subscriber return. Open and unknown calls remain null in the net table, preserving absence rather than zero-fill the missing financial history.